Your maturity date is close and the lender says no, or offers terms you cannot accept. You almost always have options, but you need to move early.
Why would a lender refuse to renew?
The usual causes are lower income, a missed payment, a falling credit score, a large new debt since you bought, or a property value judged too low. In most cases a renewal is offered automatically, with no new review. A refusal therefore signals a change in your file or in the lender's rules.
Ask for the specific reason, in writing if possible. It decides what comes next: fixing a credit issue is not the same job as finding a lender that is more flexible on income.
Can you switch lenders without a new stress test?
Often, yes. For an uninsured mortgage, OSFI removed the requirement to requalify at the minimum qualifying rate when moving from one federally regulated lender to another, provided the balance and remaining amortization do not change. Insured mortgages have a similar exemption. The new lender still reviews your file, but at your contract rate.
This exemption does not cover taking out equity or extending the amortization. If you want to add money or lengthen the term, a refinance with the full test applies. A non-federal lender may also have its own rules.
What are your options, in order?
Options when renewal is declined
| Option | Best for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Renew with the same lender on other terms | Strong file, refusal tied to a specific product | Renewal rate often above the market |
| Switch to another lender | Acceptable file, balance and amortization unchanged | File reviewed at your contract rate |
| Alternative lender (short term) | Damaged credit, hard-to-prove income | Higher rate and fees, often one year |
| Private lender | Last resort, tight timeline | High cost, exit plan required |
| Sell the property | Payments durably out of reach | Selling costs and timing |
The usual strategy for a fragile file: a short term with an alternative lender while you rebuild credit or income, then a return to a mainstream lender. It costs more each month, so put a number on the transition period.
What does a higher rate cost, in numbers?
Hypothetical example: $350,000 balance, 20 years remaining, example rates of 4.5% and then 5.5%, compounded semi-annually. The monthly payment goes from $2,206 to $2,395, which is $189 more a month and $2,267 a year. These are not current rates: see the rates page for up-to-date values.
What should you do before maturity?
- ✓Find the exact maturity date and read the renewal notice
- ✓Ask for the reason for the refusal, in writing
- ✓Get your credit report and fix any errors
- ✓Gather income documents and debt statements
- ✓Have several lenders compared at least 120 days before maturity
- ✓Sign no renewal agreement until you have compared
When is an alternative lender a good temporary choice?
An alternative lender assesses a file differently from a bank: it gives more weight to property value and equity than to credit score or income proof. In exchange, the rate is higher, fees apply, and the term is often one or two years.
The choice makes sense when the problem is temporary: an old missed payment, income that is recovering, a recent job change. It makes less sense when the ability to pay is durably too low: pushing maturity out by a year then solves nothing.
Before signing, ask for the total cost of the term (rate, fees, commissions) and what exiting would cost. Aim for a clear plan to return to a mainstream lender at the end of the term. Without a plan, the same problem comes back at the next maturity.
None of this replaces personalized advice. Lender policies, rates and the rules on switching change over time, and your options depend on the reason for the refusal and on the state of your file. Bring your renewal notice and your latest statements to the first conversation, so the comparison starts from your real situation and you keep as much time as possible before the maturity date.
Frequently asked questions
Can my lender really refuse to renew?
At maturity the contract ends and the lender has no duty to offer a new term. In practice most lenders do offer a renewal, but not for every file.
How early should I act?
The earlier the better. Comparing lenders several months before maturity leaves time to fix a problem and avoids signing under pressure.
Does a refusal hurt my credit?
A renewal refusal does not register anything by itself. Each new credit application, however, may lead to an inquiry on your file.
Can a broker help?
Yes, a broker compares several lenders and can suggest an alternative lender if banks decline. Terms vary by file.
What happens if I sign nothing?
Depending on the contract, the loan may renew automatically on the lender's terms or become due. Read the renewal notice and act before the deadline.
Sources
- OSFI, Exemption from the minimum qualifying rate for uninsured straight switches · accessed 2026-10-13
- OSFI, Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages · accessed 2026-10-13
