Going to your bank feels simpler, and using a broker feels free. Both impressions deserve some nuance.
What is the real difference between a broker and a bank?
According to the FCAC, a broker does not lend you money: they arrange the transaction by finding a lender for you. The products available vary from broker to broker, because not all of them have access to the same lenders. A bank presents its own products and rates.
General comparison (details vary by institution and file)
| Criterion | Bank | Mortgage broker |
|---|---|---|
| Products offered | The institution's own | Those of the lenders they work with |
| Role | Lends directly | Arranges the transaction and compares |
| Lender comparison | A single institution | Several lenders |
| Cost to the borrower | Depends on the institution | Generally no fees, per the FCAC |
| Atypical file (self-employed, credit rebuilding) | Depends on the bank's criteria | Possible access to other types of lenders |
How is a broker paid?
According to the FCAC, brokers generally receive a commission from the lender when they close a transaction, rather than fees from the borrower. The commission is therefore not part of your posted rate, but how it is set varies by lender and is not always itemized for the consumer.
That raises a fair question: does the broker have an incentive to steer you to a lender that pays more? Ask it plainly. A good broker explains their process, shows why they recommend an offer and presents the alternatives with their terms. Our article on questions to ask a broker gives the list.
For a bank, also ask how your advisor is compensated. Compensation models vary by institution, and I do not describe them here for lack of a verified source.
What does a small rate gap represent in dollars?
Hypothetical example: $400,000 at 4.50% (example rate), 25-year amortization, 5-year term, fixed rate compounded semi-annually. Reference payment: $2,213.89 a month. Formula: payment at the reference rate minus payment at the lower rate, then interest saved = interest paid over 5 years at the reference rate minus the same at the lower rate.
Example: what 0.10, 0.20 and 0.30 points of rate are worth over 5 years (indicative)
| Rate reduction (points) | Monthly saving | Interest saved over 5 years |
|---|---|---|
| 0.10 point | $22.18 | $1,915 |
| 0.20 point | $44.26 | $3,828 |
| 0.30 point | $66.22 | $5,740 |
A broker cannot promise a rate: they can show what different lenders offer for your file. If the gap is in this range, the comparison can be worth several thousand dollars over the term.
Whichever route you choose, compare at least four things: the contract rate, the penalty calculation method, the prepayment privileges and portability. A mortgage with a slightly higher rate but more flexible terms may suit someone who expects to sell or refinance within a few years better than the cheapest headline rate.
Which documents do I need in both cases?
The documents are the same whether you go through a bank or a broker, because the lender must confirm you can afford the payments. A broker can, however, assemble them once and present them to several lenders.
- ✓Valid ID.
- ✓Recent proof of income (pay stubs, employment letter, notices of assessment if self-employed).
- ✓Bank statements showing the down payment.
- ✓A list of debts and credit cards.
- ✓For a purchase: the offer to purchase and property details; for a renewal: your mortgage statement.
When is a broker most useful?
- You want to compare several lenders without multiplying credit applications.
- Your file is out of the ordinary: variable income, self-employed, newcomer, credit rebuilding.
- You are renewing and want competing offers to negotiate with.
- You want support in French or in English.
Who is your broker?
Your broker is a certified mortgage broker (certificate 259508) with Cloutier Services Hypothécaires. He works in French and English and compares several lenders. No approval is guaranteed: the outcome depends on your file and the lender.
Frequently asked questions
Is a mortgage broker free?
Generally they do not charge the borrower fees, according to the FCAC, and receive a commission from the lender. Ask in writing before starting, since special situations may involve fees.
Can I go to my bank after seeing a broker?
Yes. Nothing obliges you to pick an offer. Comparing your bank's offer to those the broker presents is even a good way to negotiate.
Does a broker always get me the lowest rate?
No broker can guarantee that. They compare the lenders they can access, and the result depends on your file, your down payment and timing.
Do banks and brokers ask for the same documents?
In practice yes: income, ID, down payment, debts and property details. The broker can compile them once for several lenders.
Can a broker help with a renewal?
Yes. They can get competing offers and help you negotiate, or transfer the mortgage to another lender. Start a few months before maturity.
Sources
- FCAC, Getting preapproved for a mortgage · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Renewing your mortgage · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Interest on mortgages · accessed 2026-10-13
