You want to take money out of your home without selling it. There are two routes, and they do not cost the same.
What is the difference between a home equity line and a refinance?
A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is a pool of money secured by your home. You can draw it, repay it and draw again, and you pay interest only on what you use. The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) expects lenders to keep the revolving part of such a line at or below 65% of the property's value.
A refinance replaces your current mortgage with a larger new loan, and the difference is paid to you in one amount. The legal ceiling for an uninsured loan is 80% of the value. The new loan is repaid through regular payments of principal and interest.
Line of credit or refinance: what to compare
| Criterion | Home equity line | Refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Ceiling on value | 65% for the revolving part | 80% of value |
| Access to the money | In stages, as you need it | One amount, at signing |
| Interest | Only on the amount used | On the whole new loan |
| Current mortgage | Generally stays in place | Replaced, with a possible penalty |
| Principal repayment | Optional, per the lender's contract | Imposed by the amortization |
| Fees | To check: appraisal, notary | Appraisal, notary, possible penalty |
How much can you get in a typical case?
Take a home appraised at $600,000 with a mortgage balance of $250,000. This case is hypothetical and shows the formula: value times the ceiling, minus the balance.
Example: $600,000 value, $250,000 balance (hypothetical, regulatory ceilings)
| Option | Ceiling | Calculation | Money available |
|---|---|---|---|
| Line, revolving part | 65% | $600,000 × 65% = $390,000, minus $250,000 | $140,000 |
| Refinance | 80% | $600,000 × 80% = $480,000, minus $250,000 | $230,000 |
The real amount will be lower: the lender applies its own limits, looks at your income and debts, and requires an appraisal. And with a refinance you must subtract fees and any penalty. Some lenders offer a line combined with the mortgage, reaching 80% of the value in total, with the revolving part no higher than 65%.
When is the line the better choice?
- You need modest sums, for example for renovations spread over a few months.
- Your current mortgage has a good rate and you do not want to pay a penalty to break it.
- You want an emergency reserve, used only if needed.
- You can repay quickly what you draw.
Beware: the minimum payment on a line is often interest only. If you do not repay principal yourself, the debt does not fall. The rate is generally variable, so it can change.
When is a refinance the better choice?
- You need a large sum known in advance, such as a major renovation or an investment.
- You want to consolidate high-rate debts into a single amortized loan.
- Your term is close to maturity, which limits or removes the penalty.
- You prefer a fixed rate and predictable payments.
The main cost of a refinance is the penalty for breaking your mortgage, if your term is not over. According to the FCAC, a fixed-rate penalty is normally the higher of three months of interest or the interest rate differential. As a hypothetical example, three months of interest on $250,000 at 4.5% is $250,000 × 4.5% ÷ 4 = $2,812.50.
What does the mechanical difference cost on $50,000?
Hypothetical example: $50,000 borrowed (example rates, not current rates)
| Option | Rate assumption | Monthly payment |
|---|---|---|
| Line, interest only | 6.5% (example) | $270.83 |
| 25-year amortized loan | 5% (example) | $292.30 |
The line's payment is lower, but it does not repay principal: after 25 years you still owe $50,000. The amortized loan costs more each month and ends on schedule. Formulas: $50,000 × 6.5% ÷ 12 for the line, and the standard amortization formula over 300 months for the loan.
Frequently asked questions
Is a home equity line secured by my house?
Yes. It is registered as security against the property, like a mortgage. If you do not pay, the lender can enforce that security.
Why can a refinance go to 80% when a line stops at 65%?
OSFI limits the revolving part of a line to 65%, but total secured lending can reach 80% on an uninsured loan, with an amortized portion.
Can I have a line on top of my mortgage?
Often yes, with the same lender or another, depending on value, balance and income. A different lender can complicate the file.
Is there a penalty to refinance?
If your term is not over, generally yes. It is calculated per the contract: three months of interest or the IRD, the higher for a fixed rate.
Which option is cheaper?
It depends on the amount, the duration and your term. A line for a small sum repaid quickly is often cheaper than a refinance. Compare with real numbers.
Sources
- OSFI, Clarification on the treatment of innovative real estate secured lending products under Guideline B-20 · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Home equity lines of credit · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Breaking your mortgage contract · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties · accessed 2026-10-13
