Two bank banners show 5.49% and 4.29%, and nobody tells you which one is the real rate. Both exist, but for different reasons.
What is the difference between a posted and a negotiated rate?
According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), the posted rate is the rate a lender advertises for each term. Your contract rate may be higher or lower. When it is lower, it is called a discounted rate, meaning the posted rate minus a discount.
The negotiated rate is that discount in practice: you compare offers, talk to the lender, and the contract rate reflects the result. Starting rates, discounts and promotions vary by lender, term length, down payment and file.
How much does the rate gap cost over a 5-year term?
Take a hypothetical example: a $400,000 mortgage, 25-year amortization, fixed rate compounded semi-annually, 5-year term. The 4.79% and 4.29% rates are example rates, not current ones. Formula: amortized payment, then interest paid = 60 payments minus principal repaid.
Example: same $400,000 mortgage, two rates (indicative, October 2026)
| Example rate | Monthly payment | Balance after 5 years | Interest paid in 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.79% | $2,278.83 | $352,851 | $89,581 |
| 4.29% | $2,167.43 | $349,954 | $80,000 |
| Gap | $111.40 | $2,897 | $9,581 |
A half-point gap is therefore worth about $9,600 in interest over five years. That is why you compare several lenders before signing, even when the first offer looks fine.
Why does the posted rate change my penalty?
On a fixed rate, the penalty is usually the higher of two amounts: three months' interest on the balance, or the interest rate differential (IRD). According to the FCAC, the IRD compares your contract rate to a second rate: the current posted rate for a similar term, sometimes reduced by the discount you originally received.
This is where the method matters. If the lender compares your rate to a posted rate without subtracting your discount, the penalty can be far higher than one calculated with the rates it actually offers. The method is written in your contract, and it differs from one lender to the next.
Hypothetical example: $300,000 balance, 4.00% contract rate, 36 months left
| Calculation method | Second rate | Formula | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three months' interest | n/a | $300,000 × 4.00% ÷ 4 | $3,000 |
| IRD with posted rate minus discount (5.00% - 1.50%) | 3.50% | $300,000 × 0.50% × 3 years | $4,500 |
| IRD with the rate actually offered today | 3.60% | $300,000 × 0.40% × 3 years | $3,600 |
In the last two rows the penalty is the IRD, because it exceeds three months' interest. Every number in this table is invented to illustrate the formula: always ask your lender for your exact figure in writing.
What should I do as renewal approaches?
According to the FCAC, a federally regulated lender must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before your term ends, and the rate offered will not increase before your renewal date. That letter is only a starting point, though: it often shows the posted rate or a retention rate, not the best rate you could get.
Start shopping a few months before maturity, do not sign the letter as is, and keep competing offers in writing. Your current lender knows you can leave, and that is what makes negotiation possible.
How do I read an offer without getting trapped?
- ✓Ask for the contract rate, not just the "starting from" rate.
- ✓Ask which penalty method applies (IRD on the posted rate or on the offered rate).
- ✓Compare prepayment and portability terms, not just the rate.
- ✓Check whether the rate is insured, insurable or uninsured: it depends on the down payment.
- ✓Keep the offer date: a rate is guaranteed only for a limited period.
What else should I negotiate besides the rate?
- The penalty calculation method, when the lender offers a choice.
- Portability: being able to carry the rate to a new property.
- Annual prepayment privileges.
- Transfer or assignment fees, which a new lender sometimes agrees to cover.
Frequently asked questions
Is the posted rate always higher than the negotiated rate?
Not always, but often. Your contract rate can be lower or higher than the posted rate depending on the lender, the period and your file. Only the contract counts.
Does a lower posted rate mean a better mortgage?
No. A low posted rate can come with a heavier penalty, less flexibility or fees. Compare the total cost over the term, not just the banner.
Can I negotiate when renewing with the same lender?
Yes. According to the FCAC, you may get a rate below the one in your renewal letter, especially if you show competing offers.
How do I find my exact penalty?
Your contract describes the method, and your lender should be able to give you the precise amount. Ask for it in writing before deciding to leave the mortgage.
Does a variable rate also have a posted rate?
Often yes, as the lender's prime rate plus or minus a margin. The penalty on a variable rate is usually simpler: three months' interest.
Sources
- FCAC, Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Interest on mortgages · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Renewing your mortgage · accessed 2026-10-13
- Bank of Canada, Policy interest rate · accessed 2026-10-13
