An open mortgage can be repaid whenever you like, with no penalty. A closed mortgage costs less, but it ties you in for the length of the term.
What is the difference between an open and a closed mortgage?
With an open mortgage you can pay extra amounts, in part or in full, without a penalty (Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, FCAC). In exchange, its interest rate is usually higher than a closed mortgage on similar terms.
With a closed mortgage, the extra amount you can pay each year is capped. These prepayment privileges differ from one lender to another. If you exceed the limit or break the contract, a penalty applies.
Open or closed: what to compare
| Criterion | Open | Closed |
|---|---|---|
| Partial or full repayment | No penalty, any time | Limited by the lender's privileges |
| Interest rate | Usually higher | Usually lower |
| Penalty if you break it | None | Yes, to be calculated |
| Terms offered | Often short terms, depending on the lender | Short and long terms |
| Who it suits | A sale or repayment planned soon | Most borrowers |
How much can a closed mortgage penalty cost?
According to the FCAC, the penalty on a fixed-rate loan is normally the higher of two amounts: three months of interest, or the interest rate differential (IRD). The IRD is often based on lenders' posted rates and can swing a lot when they change their rates. For a closed variable rate, the penalty is generally three months of interest.
Hypothetical example: $300,000 balance, two years left in the term
| Method | Formula | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Three months of interest (4.5% contract rate, example) | $300,000 × 4.5% ÷ 4 | $3,375 |
| IRD (1-point gap, example) | $300,000 × 1% × 2 years | $6,000 |
| Penalty charged | The higher of the two | $6,000 |
The rates in this example are invented to show the formula, and reflect no current market. Each lender has its own calculation method: ask for it in writing before signing, and ask for a statement of the exact amount before you break.
When does an open mortgage make sense?
- You have already signed a sale agreement and are waiting for the transaction to close.
- You expect a large sum (inheritance, sale of an asset, bonus) and want to repay as soon as it arrives.
- You need a bridge of a few months, for example between two properties.
- You want maximum flexibility during an uncertain period, and accept paying for it with a higher rate.
In these situations the penalty you avoid can exceed the rate premium you pay over a few months. Run the numbers with the two real rates from your quotes.
When is closed the better choice?
If you keep the property for at least the length of the term, an open mortgage makes you pay a higher rate for flexibility you will not use. A closed mortgage, with its yearly prepayment privileges, is enough for most people who want to repay faster in small amounts.
Before choosing, ask your broker about the prepayment privileges on each offer: the percentage of principal you can repay per year, how much you can raise your payments, and when those apply. These privileges can reduce your need for an open mortgage.
Can you reduce the penalty if you break a closed mortgage?
- Use your prepayment privileges in full each year.
- Make a lump-sum payment before you break, since some lenders limit payments as the break date nears.
- If the penalty is very high, wait until the end of the term.
- Ask for an early renewal through blend-and-extend, which carries no penalty (FCAC).
How do you compare the two offers in practice?
Set the open mortgage's rate premium against the penalty you would avoid. If you exit after six months and the open rate costs one point more (an invented gap, as an example), the extra cost is $300,000 × 1% × 0.5 year = $1,500. The avoided penalty in the previous example is $3,375 to $6,000, so open wins. After three years the same gap costs $9,000: closed almost always wins.
Extra cost of the open rate by time to exit (example: 1-point gap on $300,000)
| Time before exit | Calculation | Approximate extra cost |
|---|---|---|
| 6 months | $300,000 × 1% × 0.5 | $1,500 |
| 1 year | $300,000 × 1% × 1 | $3,000 |
| 3 years | $300,000 × 1% × 3 | $9,000 |
The calculation is simplified: the balance falls with each payment, so the real extra cost is slightly lower. It shows the order of magnitude, not your bill.
Frequently asked questions
Does an open mortgage cost more?
Its rate is usually higher than a closed mortgage on similar terms, according to the FCAC. The exact gap varies by lender and by timing.
Can an open mortgage be converted to closed?
Often yes, but the rules depend on the lender. Ask before signing, including the rate applied on conversion.
Is the penalty always three months of interest?
No. For a fixed rate it is the higher of three months of interest and the IRD. For a closed variable rate it is generally three months of interest.
What are prepayment privileges?
They are the amounts you can pay on top of your regular payments, with no penalty, in a closed mortgage. They differ from one lender to another.
Should I choose open if I might sell in a few years?
Not necessarily. If the sale is several years away, a closed mortgage with portability or a short term may cost less. Compare both with real numbers.
Sources
- FCAC, Mortgage prepayment: know your rights · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Choosing a mortgage that is right for you · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Breaking your mortgage contract · accessed 2026-10-13
