Getting $12,000 at signing is tempting. But that money is not a gift: it is a disguised loan that you repay through a higher rate.
How does a cash back mortgage work?
The lender pays a percentage of the loan to you in cash at closing. In return it applies a higher rate than on a comparable offer without cash back. The cash back percentage, the rate and the repayment terms vary from lender to lender.
This money is not free. You pay for it three ways: through the rate gap over the whole term, through a cash back repayment charge if you exit early, and sometimes through tighter prepayment privileges.
How much does the higher rate cost?
Take a $400,000 loan, amortized over 25 years, with a 5-year term. The rates below are hypothetical and only illustrate the calculation. The cash back is 3%, or $12,000. The table compares the extra interest paid during the term for different rate gaps.
Hypothetical example: $400,000 loan, base at 4.5% (example rate), 5-year term
| Rate gap on the cash back offer | Extra interest over 5 years | Cash back received | Net result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5 point | $9,791 | $12,000 | Gain of $2,209 |
| 1.0 point | $19,636 | $12,000 | Loss of $7,636 |
| 1.5 points | $29,529 | $12,000 | Loss of $17,529 |
Formula: interest paid over 5 years at the cash back rate, minus interest paid at the base rate, using the same loan and amortization. Even at 0.5 point the gain is only $2,209, and it vanishes as soon as part of the cash back must be repaid. Real rate gaps are not in this article: ask for them in your own offers.
What happens if you break the contract?
Breaking a closed mortgage already costs a penalty. According to the FCAC, it is normally the higher of three months of interest or the interest rate differential, and it can reach several thousand dollars. With cash back, the lender may also demand repayment of all or part of the sum you received, on top of that penalty.
We give no repayment percentage here: the formula is written in each lender's contract, and it differs. Some calculate it pro rata for the time remaining, others require the whole sum. Ask for it in writing before you sign.
What can pile up if you exit before the end of the term (example, no lender figures)
| Item | Source of the rule | Who sets it |
|---|---|---|
| Break penalty | Higher of three months of interest or IRD | Lender's contract, framed by the FCAC |
| Cash back repayment | Cash back contract | Lender, variable formula |
| Administration and discharge fees | Contract | Lender |
How do you compare a cash back offer with one that has none?
Ask for two quotes from the same lender or from two lenders, with the same term, the same amortization and the same privileges. Then calculate, over your expected holding period, total interest paid minus the cash back received. Add an estimate of what an early exit would cost if your situation could change: a move, a separation, a promotion that takes you elsewhere.
The calculation is simple, but it is rarely done at signing. Yet it is what separates a good deal from a trap. A broker can run it with you on the real offers.
Who does cash back make sense for?
- Someone who keeps the loan to the end of the term and has a real need for cash at closing (furniture, moving, work).
- When the rate gap is so small that the extra interest cost is lower than the cash back.
- When you have compared the total cost with an offer without cash back, not just the posted rate.
It rarely makes sense if you plan to sell, refinance or switch lenders before maturity, or if you want flexible prepayment privileges.
What should you ask before signing?
- What is the rate gap between this offer and the same offer without cash back?
- How much of the cash back must I repay if I sell, refinance or switch lenders, and by what formula?
- Does the cash back repayment add to the usual penalty?
- Are my prepayment privileges reduced?
- Is the term closed with no option to convert?
Frequently asked questions
Is the cash back taxable?
We could not confirm this with an official source. Ask an accountant or Revenu Québec before signing.
Can the cash back count as a down payment?
Do not count on it. The down payment must come from sources the lender accepts, and the cash back is only paid at closing. Ask the lender what it accepts before building your budget.
Is the rate always higher with cash back?
That is the general rule: the lender funds the cash back through a higher rate. The exact gap varies, so always compare the two offers side by side.
Can I refuse to repay the cash back when I break the contract?
No, the clause is in the contract you sign. If in doubt, ask for the exact formula before signing.
Is cash back available at renewal?
It depends on the lender. Ask in your renewal comparisons, using the same total cost conditions.
Sources
- FCAC, Breaking your mortgage contract · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Mortgage prepayment: know your rights · accessed 2026-10-13
- FCAC, Choosing a mortgage that is right for you · accessed 2026-10-13
