Two reports come up in almost every purchase: the appraisal and the inspection. They look alike, but they serve different people and lead to different decisions.
What is the difference between an appraisal and an inspection?
An appraisal answers one question: is the property worth enough to secure the loan? A certified appraiser compares it with recent comparable sales in the area. The report is addressed to the lender.
An inspection answers another question: what shape is the building in? A building inspector looks at the roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical, heating and visible moisture. The report goes to the buyer, who uses it to negotiate, ask for repairs or walk away.
Appraisal and inspection side by side
| Point of comparison | Appraisal | Building inspection |
|---|---|---|
| Who orders it | The lender (or the broker on the lender's behalf) | The buyer |
| Question it answers | What is the market value? | What is the condition of the building? |
| Who receives the report | The lender | The buyer |
| Who pays | Varies by lender and file | Usually the buyer |
| Possible effect on the loan | Can reduce the amount lent | None automatically, unless the lender requires repairs |
| Possible effect on the deal | Price renegotiation or a larger down payment | Negotiation, repairs or withdrawing the offer |
Who pays for the appraisal?
It depends on the lender, the type of loan and sometimes the file. Some lenders absorb the cost as part of their offer, others bill the borrower, and others only require an appraisal for certain files. There is no single rule.
Good practice is to ask before you apply: does the lender require an appraisal, who orders it, what does it cost, and is the fee refundable if the file does not proceed? Get the answer in writing.
Who pays for the inspection?
Normally the buyer, because the inspection protects the buyer's interests first. The seller has no obligation to pay for it. The inspection is most often written into the offer to purchase as a condition, with a deadline to carry it out and to react to the report.
Choose the inspector yourself. Check qualifications, professional liability insurance and a sample report. An inspector suggested by the seller, or by someone who earns a commission on the sale, raises a question of independence.
What does the lender do with the appraisal?
The lender lends on the lower of two values: the purchase price or the appraised value. If the appraisal comes in under the price, the loan is calculated on the lower figure. The gap has to be covered another way.
Hypothetical example: appraisal below purchase price (indicative parameters, October 13, 2026)
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Agreed purchase price | $500,000 |
| Appraised value | $480,000 |
| Target loan (80% of price) | $400,000 |
| Maximum loan at 80% of the value used (480,000 × 0.80) | $384,000 |
| Extra down payment needed (400,000 − 384,000) | $16,000 |
| Total down payment (500,000 − 384,000) | $116,000 |
The formula: maximum loan = value used × permitted financing percentage. The 80% figure is only an example. The permitted ratio varies by loan type, property type and lender. This table is not a financing offer.
What does the lender do with the inspection report?
In most files the lender does not ask for your inspection report. It relies on the appraisal. Still, the inspection can affect financing indirectly.
- If the inspection reveals a major defect (water infiltration, foundation, electrical), the price or sale terms may change, and so may the loan.
- If the appraiser notes a defect that affects value or safety, the lender can require repairs or a holdback before releasing funds.
- Riskier properties (older buildings, unusual heating, problem materials) call for comparing several lenders, since their policies differ.
- A home insurer may also set conditions based on the building's condition, which matters before you take possession.
In what order should you do things?
- ✓Confirm your borrowing capacity before visiting, with a broker or a lender.
- ✓Include a financing condition and an inspection condition in the offer, with realistic deadlines.
- ✓Ask the lender whether an appraisal will be required, who orders it and who pays.
- ✓Book an inspector as soon as the offer is accepted, since calendars fill quickly.
- ✓Read the whole inspection report, not just the summary, and talk to your broker if work is likely.
- ✓Keep a cash cushion for an appraisal gap or repairs.
Frequently asked questions
Can I rely on my lender's appraisal instead of an inspection?
No. An appraisal estimates market value, not the detailed condition of the building. Only an inspection tells you about the systems and visible defects.
Is the appraisal fee refunded if my file does not proceed?
That depends on the lender's terms. Ask in writing, before it is ordered, whether the fee is refundable and in which cases.
Can a low appraisal be challenged?
Often yes, by submitting recent comparable sales the appraiser did not use. The lender then decides whether to review it. Your broker can prepare the request.
Do I have to give my inspection report to the lender?
Not systematically. If the report reveals a problem affecting the value or safety of the property, your broker will tell you how to handle it in the financing request.
Is an inspection mandatory in Quebec?
No, but it is strongly recommended, especially for an older building. It is usually included as a condition of the offer to purchase.
Sources
- CMHC, Buying a home: inspection and appraisal · accessed 2026-10-13
- OACIQ, Guide for buyers · accessed 2026-10-13
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Mortgages · accessed 2026-10-13
